Lot # 69: Ed Delahanty 1894 Honest Duke N142 Cabinet PSA 4 VG-EX – Highest Graded Example on the Planet!

Category: Pre-1900

Starting Bid: $5,000.00

Bids: 20 (Bid History)

Time Left: Auction closed
Lot / Auction Closed

This lot is closed. Bidding is not allowed.

Item was in Auction "Fall Rarities Auction 2021",
which ran from 9/25/2021 12:00 PM to
10/9/2021 7:00 PM

(LOT 69)
Ed Delahanty 1894 Honest Duke N142 Cabinet PSA 4 VG-EX – Highest Graded Example on the Planet!

In 1894, the New York based Duke Company distributed what are arguably considered the most visually striking 19th-century cabinet cards to promote their "Honest Tobacco" brand. Measuring 6" x 9-½", these museum worthy masterpieces consist of ultra-thick cardboard stock and include breathtaking color lithographs of four popular 19th-century stars. Unquestionably, the most prestigious of the four players is the majestic Hall of Famer Ed Delahanty in what is his most artistic cardboard subject issued in either century. Virtually never surfacing for the taking, the "Honest Duke" Delahanty N142 cabinet card has eluded even elite enthusiasts, who carefully watch for the next available specimen. Well, as luck would have it, the "Queen Mary" has now arrived, as we are proud to offer this seldom seen artifact in what is the hobby's foremost example, a miraculous PSA VG-EX 4 memento.

Currently, the combined PSA and SGC "Pop" Charts list only nine examples (2 - PSA; 7 - SGC), with this offering sharing the spotlight as the finest of its kind with a single other SGC 4 specimen! So why is this Delahanty cabinet coveted by a hoard of 19th-century enthusiasts? First & foremost, it represents the incomparable "Big Ed" who just might reside as the most coveted 19th-century Hall of Famer (with all due respect to Cap Anson and Buck Ewing). Over 15-plus seasons, Delahanty accumulated 2,597 hits, batted over .400 three times and finished his career with a sensational .346 lifetime batting average. He also owns the rare distinction of winning a batting title in both the National (Phillies) and American (Senators) Leagues. Unfortunately, his career ended in tragedy when in 1903 after drinking too much, he allegedly stumbled off a train crossing over Niagara Falls and plunged to his untimely death.

Yet, synonymous with the immortal Lou Gehrig and Roberto Clemente, Delahanty's tragic death has practically solidified his sanctified legacy, forever branding him as a baseball icon with an eternal resting place in Cooperstown, New York. The additional argument for capturing one of these hallowed Honest Duke Delahanty cabinets is that while there are a handful of other Delahanty issues to choose from Old Judge, Mayo Cut Plug, W600 cabinet, etc., they simply cannot compete against the aesthetic brilliance of his ultra-colorful Honest Duke Cabinet that suffices as one of the few 19th-century cabinet issues utilizing colored hues for their player images. Considering this Delahanty cabinet is now 127 years old, the eye appeal of the sparkling central image is miraculous to say the least. The critical portrait pose appears as pristine as its original production date, depicting a spectacular array of grey, red and light green hues that vividly define Delahanty's timeless image.

The edging has remained intact including minimal wear to its factory-issued curved corners that portray a super eye pleasing uniformity. No obtrusive creasing and/or surface blemishes are evident, and the somewhat toned verso is relatively clean. Accounting for the technical grade is some negligible lower edge toning as well as some stray diminutive surface abrasions/notches primarily situated along the upper and right edges, none of which impeding the stellar Delahanty central image. The final compliments are the relatively clean surfaces, and the bold "Honest – E.J. DELEHANTY – NEW YORK" verbiage situated along the lower border (misspelled "Delahanty"). One of the most breathtaking cards from any century, its "highest graded" stature, unquestionable paucity level (only nine encapsulated examples) and absolutely brilliant "Big Ed" illustration all combine to place this 19th-century "Holy Grail" as one of the most momentous cabinets extant!

MIN BID $5,000

Views: 287