Lot # 5: 1951 Bowman #253 Mickey Mantle Rookie Card PSA 8 NM-MT

Category: 1950-1959

Starting Bid: $75,000.00

Bids: 28 (Bid History)

Time Left: Auction closed
Lot / Auction Closed




This lot is closed. Bidding is not allowed.

Item was in Auction "Fall Rarities Auction 2021",
which ran from 9/25/2021 12:00 PM to
10/9/2021 7:00 PM




(LOT 5)
1951 Bowman #253 Mickey Mantle Rookie Card PSA 8 NM-MT

While the 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle subject may stand as the post-WWII's most iconic card, it is Mantle's 1951 Bowman subject that resides as his true rookie card. Along with the majestic Babe Ruth inaugural card, the 1951 Bowman Mantle rookie arguably stands as the most coveted rookie card in the entire collecting community. The seemingly infinite rise of Mantle's sanctified 1952 Topps subject has likewise propelled the value of his inaugural 1951 Bowman issue, with the sale of a PSA 8 example in March 2021 resulting in a staggering $612K price tag and Memory Lane fetching nearly $500K for Dr. Newman's PSA 8 example. Presented here is a compelling example of the iconic Mickey Mantle rookie card, a breathtaking PSA NM-MT 8 gem that has only been bested by a mere ten PSA specimens. Imagine, of the 2,300+ encapsulated copies, only ten finer examples have been handled by PSA with a microscopic 2.3% achieving the hallowed "NM-MT 8" assessment. Incredibly, "Near Mint-Mint 8" examples were selling for less than $200K only a few years ago, with the recent rookie card frenzy propelling the '51 Mantle, from a value perspective, to its rightful place.

Considering that a PSA 8 '52 Topps Mantle has now sold for $2.1 million, it makes perfect sense that the 1951 Bowman "true rookie" would likewise realize a meteoric rise in value. Even the aforementioned $612K record sale for a PSA 8 still resides at only 29% or a mere fraction of the '52 Topps $2.1 million record sale. At the time this was written, while the population disparity of 1951 Bowman versus 1952 Topps Mantles PSA 8 "specimens" stood at roughly 50% ('53 Bowman Mantles vs. '53 Topps Mantles), the value disproportion exceeds 300%+ in some instances. Therefore, it makes perfect sense that the pricing points will continue to soar for "The Mick's" inaugural cardboard memento, with the '51 Bowman still retaining immense growth potential to close that significant imbalanced value gap. Regardless of how the Mickey Mantle mystique was established, no one will argue that Mantle's 1951 Bowman image will forever be embedded in hobby lore, standing tall as one of the most significant rookie cards on the planet. Mantle's supernatural-like power ably assisted his mammoth sized tape measure home runs, bolstering "The Mick's" legendary stature that has led to his insatiable cardboard frenzy. He was Goliath, Davy Crockett, John Wayne and Joe DiMaggio all rolled up into one super icon, truly establishing himself as the true embodiment of a National hero.

We cannot think of a more formidable card to better represent the strength of our hobby than Mickey Mantle's inaugural cardboard issue, treasured by every young boy who grew up worshiping the "Commerce Comet". The seemingly timeless "bat over shoulder" lithographic pose with Mickey's #6 (vs. his famous #7) partly showing on his uniform was taken from a classic 1951 photograph from Mantle's rookie season. Virtually all of the qualities associated with this legendary picture are pristine including vibrant gray/blue colored hues, immaculate contrast/resolution and a flawless sky-blue background. The extremely well-centered image atypically falls within the approximate "45/55" range between four snow white borders, only slightly favoring the upper right edges. As meticulous collectors are well aware, this is a critical attribute since most examples reflect skewed illustrations. A razor-sharp perimeter boasts four pinpoint corners, the obverse side surface glistens with a pack-fresh aura, and the super clean verso has eluded any serious gum stains that typically plague this issue.

Many enthusiasts would surely agree this miraculous offering's eye appeal is consistent with a handful of the few existing "Near Mint 9" examples in circulation due to the immaculate central image and highly sought-after fine centering. To reiterate, the "true" Mickey Mantle rookie card holds an unbridled place in the hobby that is surpassed by only a handful of cards, with the mere sight of a high-grade specimen immediately arousing the utmost attention of any sophisticated hobbyist. Along with the 1952 Topps Mantle that continues to soar in value, high-grade '51 Bowman Mantle subjects are likewise realizing escalating price tags that one would assume will continue "narrowing the gap" versus the overwhelming pricing delta of the 1952 Topps Mantle. Considering it resides as Mantle's irrefutable inaugural card, it still remains significantly undervalued as opposed to its 1952 Topps brethren, justifying why it may ultimately become the hobby's next "seven-figure+" cardboard icon!

MIN BID $75,000
_

Views: 903